How the ‘F’ word determined a court case

Ross Greenwood gives a hilarious classification of events that happened in The Federal Court today after it was found Westpac engaged in unconscionable conduct by trying to rig the bill swap rate in 2010.

But at the centre of the case is the interpretation of a choice word.

Unbelievably, the case came down to the interpretation of the ‘f word’ by Westpac trader, Colin ‘The Rat’ Roden.

Ross Greenwood: At the center of the court case regarding Westpac and ASIC and whether Westpac traders had sought to manipulate the bank bill swap rate, is the word [beep] as Justice Jonathan Beach said in the federal court judgment today the [beep] word has been in many forms in English language.

It is in fact one of our most interpretive words as Justice Beach said in his ruling. The [beep] word and its use by the traders in the present context is a classic example. It’s been used as both a transitive and intransitive verb, that’s what he said.

Well, as a transitive verb that would be like John [beep] Mary. As an intransitive verb that would be like Mary was [beep] by John. It’s been in an active sense also a passive sense as Justice Beach said. He said, “In an active way I’d say that it would be, well I don’t give a [beep] or in a passive way it would be [beep] me.”

It’s been used in the past tense and the future tense. I am [beep] or I’ll be [beep]. It’s been used as adjective, that’s [beep] unbelievable. It’s been used a noun, including as a verbal noun, you are a silly [beep]. Even as an adverb, that is really [beep] interesting.

In this case, Justice Beach had to interpret the use of the word [beep] by the Westpac trader Colin Roden. Better known in the market as the Rat. The Rat Roden was recorded as he was trading, as they are. He said the he was going to [beep] the market.

Did that actually mean that he going to manipulate the market and that’s what Justice Beach had to decide. As it turns out that he ruled that Westpac tried to manipulate the bank bill swap rate market but failed.

In other words it [beep] up.

 

Recommended

9News: Deal Reached .

Interviewed  Professor John Sheehan, Chairman, Desane titled ” Small business takes State Government to court over Westconnex, and wins .”

Interviewed  Clive Palmer, Businessman and former Politician, titled ” Clive Palmer hits out, claims ‘government agenda’ behind charges .”

Interviewed  Rod Sims, Chairman, ACCC titled ” ACCC brings Telstra to court again .”

Interviewed  Denita Wawn, CEO, Master Builders Association titled ” Will there be a ‘super union’? .”

9News: Real Estate Turmoil .

Interviewed  Pauline Hanson, Leader,One Nation Party titled ” Why won’t One Nation back Company Tax Cuts? .”

Interviewed  Rod Sims, Chairman, ACCC titled ” Why is the ACCC taking Ashley & Martin to court .”

Interviewed  Framy Browne, Head of Family Law, Lavan titled ” High Court tears up millionaire’s prenup .”

Interviewed  Rob Taber, New England Solar, Owner titled ” Who is Barnaby up against? .”

Interviewed  George Williams, Constitutional Expert, UNSW titled ” What does no Deputy Prime Minister mean for Australia? .”

Interviewed  Steve Baxter, Founder, River City Labs titled ” Is the NBN a disaster? .”

Interviewed  Kelly O’Dwyer, Minister, Revenue and Financial Services titled ” Will Corporate penalties triple? .”

Interviewed  Matthew Warren, CEO, Australian Energy Council titled ” Will the new energy plan work? .”

Interviewed  Milan Cukic,, Bannister Law titled ” Shareholders are angry – but do they have a reason? .”

Interviewed  Martin North, Principal,Digital Financial Analytics titled ” Was the ATM fee removal just a PR stunt? .”

Interviewed  Rod Sims, Chairman, ACCC titled ” ACCC loses Federal Court case against Medibank .”

Interviewed  Michael Gudinski, Head, Frontier Touring  titled ” ACCC versus Viagogo: A NOgogo .”

Interviewed  Anna Bligh, CEO, Australian Bankers Association titled ” Banks threaten court action .”

Image source: 2GB

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

306 More posts in Frequently Asked Question (FAQ) category
Recommended for you
Has the government turned the corner on power prices?

Ross Greenwood speaks to Energy Minister, Josh Frydenberg, after he admits the government is keeping households...